Skip to main content

Written by Carol Godette  |  Photos provided (Unless Noted)

A view of Keuka Lake circa 1910.
Photo: Finger Lakes Wine Museum


I never expected a glass of wine at the Keuka Spring Vineyards tasting room to unfold a story reaching back to prehistoric times. Yet once again, Saratoga Springs' reputation as a crossroads of history, curiosity, and unexpected connections made the implausible happen.  This fall, nearly a year into its own Spring Street storefront, I learned about the vineyard’s humble beginnings. The irony of a wine satellite in Saratoga Springs, named Keuka Springs and located on our well-known Spring Street, was not lost on me.

A Stubborn Vine

For a century it was believed that European grapes could not be grown in The Finger Lakes region. In the 1950s, viticulturist Konstantin Frank disproved the assumption and the area is now home to over 144 vineyards and wineries - including Keuka Spring Vineyards.

NATURE SETS THE STAGE

The beautiful brick-walled back room details the now award-winning vineyard’s history, starting in 20,000 B.C. when the Laurentide Ice Sheet carved the Finger Lakes' unique topography.

A large display panel explains: “The water mass of such deep lakes has a profound effect on viticulture. In spring, cool air delays the start of the growth so that the tender shoots are not injured by late frosts. In the fall, the warm lakes prevent early frost and extend the growing season.”

Image: Finger Lakes Wine Museum

PEOPLE TAKE A CHANCE

This once improbable area for wine growing began nearly two centuries ago in 1829 when a minister planted Concord grapevines in his rectory garden. Childhood memories of Welch’s grape jelly and grape juice, a staple on our breakfast table, immediately came to mind.

Reverend Bostwick’s grapes did not produce an award-winning wine.

For the next hundred years, it was believed that European vinifera grapes could not be grown in the harsh climates of upstate New York.  Then, in 1951, a Ukrainian-born viticulturist named Konstantin Frank arrived in New York speaking no English and took a job washing dishes. Within a few years, Charles Fournier, the French champagne maker running Gold Seal Vineyards on Keuka Lake, hired him to try the impossible. Frank tested dozens of rootstocks, and by 1958 he had bought his own land on the lake. The skeptics were wrong.

Dr. Frank’s efforts eventually led to over 144 vineyards and wineries in the Finger Lakes that are currently in operation.

A Toast to history!
Friends enjoy a summer visit to Kueka Spring Vineyards’ Saratoga tasting room, where every sip comes with a story of the Finger Lakes’ rich winemaking heritage.

A FAMILY BUILDS A VINEYARD

Keuka Spring Vineyard’s website explains “Len and Judy Wiltberger founded Keuka Spring Vineyards in 1985, planting 12 acres on the hillside now known as Vista Ridge Vineyard. Chosen for its ideal soils, this site also boasts stunning views and a natural spring that still provides our water today.”

The vineyard was then bought by the Simmons family. Their website states, “Annette and Jeff Simmons, vineyard owners for over 45 years, acquired Keuka Spring Vineyards in 2022. Guided by the belief that ‘life happens at the table,’ and that wine serves as a catalyst to build community and inspire joy. They are dedicated to raising the profile of Finger Lakes wines, and they strive to create a welcoming space where people can gather, connect, and celebrate.

Family is at the heart of their vision—with their children Madison, Georgia, her husband Charles, Neil-Walker, Miles, Lila, and Baker.”

The Simmons Family
Pictured above is Neil and Joyce Simmons: Jeff Simmons parents and first generation grape growers.

THE STORY COMES TO SARATOGA

But why would an established Finger Lakes vineyard choose Saratoga Springs for its first satellite tasting room?

According to Autumn Manning, Keuka Spring Vineyards’ Eastern New York Regional Manager, Saratoga’s thriving restaurant scene, international visitors, and appreciation for fine food and wine made it an attractive choice. The winery first tested the market with a modest 300-square-foot space in the Saratoga Marketplace, where customers sampled its award-winning wines from plastic cups. Two years later, its success led to the current, much larger storefront, which opened in December 2025.

I invited my neighbor Joe McCully, a foodie and wine expert, to a tasting at the Spring Street location. Joe taught food and wine courses at Lane Community College in Eugene, Oregon, so I knew he'd bring a trained palate and Willamette Valley-style questions I wouldn’t think of asking.

As Joe reminded me of the 5S’s – sight, swirl, smell, sip, and savor we found ourselves drawn to different wine varietals that our expert Autumn shared with us. Joe enjoyed a 2025 classic Chardonnay and its stainless-steel fermentation, along with the Cabernet Franc. I was drawn to the Classic Riesling with its slightly acidic taste as well as the Miller’s Cove Red that was soft-bodied and smooth.

Both of us were impressed with the backroom’s historical posters and the large display of wine bottles encasing two walls. Autumn’s knowledgeable and friendly demeanor helped me realize why this tasting room has become such a success.

Keuka Spring tasting room on Spring Street

sight, swirl, smell,
sip, and savor
Keuka Spring Vineyards' satellite tasting room is located on Spring Street in Saratoga.

And the future?

Saratoga Springs was built on mineral water. For more than two centuries, visitors have come to drink from our springs and "take the waters."  Who would have guessed that a Finger Lakes winery would one day be pouring wine in the same town? What Saratoga offers is what it has always offered: an audience. Autumn says visitors from as far as New Zealand and Australia stop in, and many go on to discover the Finger Lakes themselves. Saratoga is not becoming Napa. But it may be becoming a front door to New York wine country.